IP Software Comparisions

Basic Image Processing

FeatureImageJ*Nikon ElementsPMODPhotoshop CS5 Ex.
LUT adjustments — Brightness, contrast, pseudo-coloring Yes — arbitrary Yes — linear and gamma only Yes — linear and gamma only Yes — arbitrary
Convolution-based filtering — Smoothing, sharpening, edge detection, etc. Yes Yes Yes Yes
Frequency-based filtering FFT, inverse FFT Yes Yes Yes No
Simple Threshholding Yes Yes — advanced Yes Yes
Binary Processing — Erode, Dilate, Open, Close etc. Yes Yes Yes No
Morphometry (Binary shape analysis) Yes Yes No No
Isocontour segmentation Yes No Yes No
Rotate, crop, resize Yes Yes Yes — also in 3D Yes
Stack support Yes Yes — advanced Yes Yes — limited
ROI (region of interest) support Yes Yes Yes Yes

Advanced Image Processing

FeatureImageJ*Nikon ElementsPMODPhotoshop CS5 Ex.
Insight Tool Kit (ITK) filters No No Yes No
VOI (volume of interest) support No Limited Yes No
Macro extensible Yes — and open source Not really No Sort of (scripts)
Object-counting/classification Yes Yes No No
Co-localization analysis Yes Yes (no curve fitting) No No
Arbitrary Plane Re-slicing Yes No Yes No
3D Segmentation No Yes Yes No

Rendering

FeatureImageJ*Nikon ElementsPMODPhotoshop CS5 Ex.
Multi-channel display Practically, up to 3 ch Yes Up to 2 No (but layers available)
Volume Rendering — MIP, mIP, Surfaces Yes Yes — Advanced with perspective MIP, mIP only No
Movie compilation Basic (XYT) Advanced (XYZT) arbitrary views Good (XYZT) – viewpoints limited No
Multi-channel blend/merge/overlay Basic Yes — advanced Yes — advanced Blend & overlay

Drawing

FeatureImageJ*Nikon ElementsPMODPhotoshop CS5 Ex.
Basic Markup Limited Limited No Advanced — Extensive
Advanced Drawing No No No Advanced — Extensive
Advanced Text Editing No No No Advanced — Extensive

* ImageJ is an open source Java application that can be extend to almost any image processing task — if you know how to program. The capabilities listed here refer to the "standard" ImageJ install and plugins currently (2010) available on the ImageJ website.